I somewhat agree with Sherry when she made the point “a
healthy fear of failure” will actually motivate students to work harder. The
reason I agree with that is because one of my teachers called my parents and
told them I was flunking a class and wouldn’t be able to graduate. I was
devastated, and I was really struggling with that class. It was chemistry, and
the teacher could care less if you knew the material or not. I had no one to
help me, and none of my friends were taking the class. The thought of not
graduating with my friends would have crushed me. Instead of trying and talking
to the teacher, I ended up getting a chemistry tutor, and I spent hours on
homework. I knew that I was smart enough to pass the class, but I just didn’t
have the motivation to try hard enough until she told me that I may not
graduate. I ended up passing the class with a solid B, and I had never felt
more relieved. This is why I agree with what she was saying. All I needed was a
little fear of failure, and that put me on track.
The reason I do not agree with her is because of what
happened to half of my senior class in high school. Most of them were told that
they were going to fail, and instead of trying harder, they just wondered what
the point was anymore. So, they dropped out. Sure, that may be the easy way out
for some people, but I understand where they are coming from. If you don’t have
parents or teachers that care, then what is the point in trying to pass a class?
I think that if a teacher tells a kid they are flunking then maybe they should
try and help, because if a student doesn’t have support at their house, than they
will look for other things to help them just pass. I thought this was a great
essay, and I did enjoy reading it very much.